Repository navigation
docs(governance): record accepted session and Host review scope - #7214
Conversation
Signed-off-by: LoopX Agent <337587101+loopx-agent@users.noreply.github.com>
loopx-agent
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Reviewer: model_agent; gpt-6.1-sol; OpenAI; runtime_reported; reasoning_effort=max
Approval conclusion (author-owned PR; GitHub blocks formal self-approval) — APPROVE at c2977dc341342fd5503034f5c1447227e3a0dcda.
动机
维护者为会话或宿主恢复问题寻找首位技术评审者时,需要知道贡献者实际接受的范围与可用性。
旧名册只写九月接受的会话范围,十月公开确认已包含同一会话边界内的宿主恢复;提案把扩展范围、尽力参与及明确排除项写回原行。
公开确认与原名册之间的缺口得到准确对齐,原有代码所有者资格和权限边界保持。
本提案不授予 Maintain、代码所有权、发布或绕过保护权限,也不把尽力参与改为固定响应承诺。
改动思路
更新既有名册即可完成这项公开文档提案。职责来自贡献者明确接受的同一会话边界,Host 指宿主集成中的恢复表面;它没有扩大到所有宿主政策。继续保留原文会使技术路由落后于公开确认;另建名册或同时修改任命路线则会引入本次没有接受的新职责。
具体改动
完整差异为 .github/GOVERNANCE.md 一份文件、增加两行并删除两行。规范固定在改动前 0c0d3dd31e865782f653ea3195ef36d8fac7b395 的 .github/GOVERNANCE.md:First-Review Responsibilities — implemented,准确记录自愿的首位技术响应范围;Code Owner Eligibility — implemented,保留独立资格与任命流程。
关键内容讲解
- 观察日期与原行:日期推进到十月二十四日,原联系人记录同时保留九月初始接受与本次扩展的来源。
- 接受范围、可用性与排除项:与贡献者公开确认逐项一致,包括 resume/submit/close、请求幂等、聚焦回归、后续维护及同一会话边界的恢复。明确 best effort、没有固定 SLA,不包含共享 Goal/quota/lease、权威提升、provider 激活和发布/绕过决定。
- 原资格条款与
CODEOWNERS均未变化;只读 GitHub 权限读回为 Write,文档没有把它写成 Maintain 或代码所有权。
对主干的风险
最强风险是把首位评审联系人误读为权限任命。已对照维护者原邀请、贡献者完整确认、周边回退条款及完整 base/head 差异;当前行明确保留相关排除项。两项现有代码所有者路由测试通过,四项直接检查和一项公共边界检查通过,精确范围质量回执 cqr_d0df0c8863935e0f41e2 冷读一致。首次 premerge 的旧质量回执状态仍留存;更新本次准确范围后,原生 premerge 通过。没有查询或等待 CI,也没有执行权限、任命或合并操作。
我的整体评价
这项有限的名册提案为 goal_achieved,没有发现阻断项。long_horizon 保持:没有制造定时义务或强制响应;user_experience 改善在既有入口找到当前联系人与边界的准确性。复用原行足够,没有需要本次继续扩大的重构。
已检查 .github/GOVERNANCE.md 的原名册、资格条款及完整差异;本次只更新既有文档内容,没有产品布局、控件或文档展示框架变化。 名册仍是待合入提案,未来实际响应、持续参与和任命资格不由本次文档评审证明。
English verdict: APPROVE at c2977dc341342fd5503034f5c1447227e3a0dcda. The existing roster faithfully records the public accepted session/Host scope and best-effort availability. Write is verified; CODEOWNERS, appointment criteria and excluded authority remain unchanged. Two route tests and scoped premerge pass. This COMMENTED approval conclusion grants no appointment or merge authority.
Goal And Delivered Outcome
The first-review roster still described Duang777's September session-only scope. Record the accepted 24 October scope, including Host/recovery surfaces within the same cohesive session boundary and best-effort availability without a fixed SLA.
main. Related to Scoped review invitations and module stewardship #4069; does not close the community scope tracker.Author Declaration
Written by: model_agent — Codex (OpenAI).
Implemented against
Specification: the public acceptance linked above and
.github/GOVERNANCE.mdat base0c0d3dd31e865782f653ea3195ef36d8fac7b395..github/GOVERNANCE.md.github/GOVERNANCE.mdScope And Continuation
Complete within this documentation proposal. Write remains active. This does not grant Maintain, code ownership, release or bypass authority. Shared goal/quota/lease policy, canonical-authority promotion and provider activation remain excluded. Any future code-owner appointment still follows the existing review qualification and separate PR process.
Validation
c2977dc341342fd5503034f5c1447227e3a0dcda.uv run --extra test python -m pytest -q tests/test_codeowners.py: 2 passed.cqr_33a4664dd934916af833; safe-fix passes: 0, blockers: 0.Visual Evidence
UI impact: none. Prose roster update only; no product layout, interaction or documentation chrome changes. Screenshots: N/A.
Boundary Checklist